FDA will be ‘laughed out of court’ if it sticks to its guns on supplement-specific NDI notifications

By NutraIngredients

The argument – contained in the FDA’s controversial new draft guidance on NDI notifications – has provoked a storm of controversy in the supplements trade, with critics claiming it was never the intent of Congress and would force firms to submit thousands of unnecessary regulatory filings.

But if the FDA sticks to its guns and the issue is tested in court, it could be on shaky ground, claimed American Herbal Products Association (AHPA) president Michael McGuffin.

The FDA has got this wrong

McGuffin, who was speaking to NutraIngredients-USA after attending a town hall meeting hosted by Senator Orrin Hatch to discuss the much-maligned guidance, said the FDA’s stance on this issue was untenable, as well as impractical.

“The FDA has got this wrong. Let’s say it says to a company ‘we’ve found this supplement and it contains an NDI – which you have notified us about – but you have now combined the NDI with chamomile without submitting a new NDI notification for the supplement’. Well the company will go to court, and the FDA will be laughed out of court.”

He added: “What they have told us for 16.9 years is that the NDI notification is for the ingredient, and then on July 5, 2011 [when the draft guidance was published], they say, what we really mean is that it’s for supplements. Well that’s not what the law says.

“You can twist the meaning of the word ‘it’ in the middle of one paragraph [of the Dietary Supplements Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994], but the industry won’t tolerate a misreading of the law.”

How many NDI notifications should have been filed?

However, it was very clear that more NDI notifications should have been filed since DSHEA was passed, accepted McGuffin.

“Do I think that NDI notifications have been submitted for every new dietary ingredient introduced to the market since DSHEA? No, I do not. There is no doubt that the NDI notification process has not been well-managed by the FDA or by industry.”

Coordinated response

Bosses of the five industry associations represented at Sen. Hatch’s town hall event inUtahthis week had discussed how to coordinate their response to the guidance in a private meeting before the public meeting started, he said.

“We will almost certainly file comments individually, because we all have different styles and members. However, we might include a group statement at the top of all of our comments, or submit a unified statement or comment as a group as well.”

While various options were also being explored in the event that the FDA proved unwilling to make substantial revisions to the guidance, Congressional oversight was a “last resort”, he stressed. “This is something you talk about after everything else has been exhausted.”

NDI guidance

According to the draft guidance, NDI notifications should be supplement-specific, not ingredient-specific, and are applicable only to the specific manufacturer that submits them.

Firms making changes to formulas, target groups or conditions of use for supplements containing NDIs must also prepare separate notifications for each new supplement.

Click here to read more about the town hall event inUtah.

Tell the FDA their Draft Guidance on NDIs is Bad for Consumers

Also: Tell Congress to Oppose the Dietary Supplement Labeling Act

7 responses to “FDA will be ‘laughed out of court’ if it sticks to its guns on supplement-specific NDI notifications

  1. Jose Bulatao, Jr.

    What is NOT SO FUNNY is: How much will this cost to go through the court system if this is thing is dragged out before it’s fixed? The bureaucratic approach of “having this thing figured out” can go on for years! Will the consumers be stuck with footing the bill on this one? It ain’t funny!

  2. Right… and it is also not funny to have to go head to head with the friggin FDA… they are grossly overstepping and have been fraudulent for too long.

  3. We need to step up to the plate and they need to be hammered on this one. Because they are like a little child, give them an inch and they will take a mile, they need to be stopped.

    Doc Blake

    “How smooth must be the language of the whites, when they can make right look like wrong, and wrong like right.”
    Black Hawk, Sauk (1767-1838) Ma-ka-tai-me-she-kia-kiak.

    Doc Blake

  4. Yeah sure… they will be laughed out of court… now go back to sleep… nothing happening here.

  5. The FDA isn’t even doing a good job with identifying harmful drugs. Why are they meddling with the supplement industry which has gotten along fine without their interference?

What do YOU think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s